Sustainable Synthesis of Bismuth Vanadate Nanomaterials: A Critical Comparison of Plant-Assisted and Conventional Routes for Visible-Light Water Treatment
Bismuth vanadate (BiVO₄) is a visible-light-responsive semiconductor widely investigated for photocatalytic oxidation and photoelectrochemical applications. Plant-assisted synthesis has attracted interest as a potential means of modifying precursor chemistry and reducing dependence on selected synthetic additives. Nevertheless, biological origin alone is not evidence of environmental superiority. This critical narrative review evaluates plant-assisted and conventional BiVO₄ synthesis through a route–material–function framework, considering precursor chemistry, phase formation, morphology, optical response, photocatalytic test quality, reproducibility, process inputs, and environmental safety. Published reviews document plant-mediated BiVO₄ preparations using different botanical extracts, while conventional precipitation, hydrothermal, solvothermal, and sol–gel approaches provide established means of controlling crystallisation and morphology. The evidence also shows why route labels cannot be used as proxies for sustainability: plant-assisted preparations may require extraction, washing, drying, and high-temperature annealing, whereas conventional processes vary substantially in reagent hazards, yield, energy demand, and purification requirements. Reported photocatalytic efficiencies are difficult to compare directly because studies use different pollutants, concentrations, catalyst loadings, light sources, and analytical endpoints. In particular, loss of a dye absorbance peak is not equivalent to mineralisation or detoxification. We propose a transparent comparison framework based on verified product characteristics, matched treatment conditions, measured process inputs and outputs, catalyst recovery, leaching, and an explicitly defined functional unit. The literature supports the feasibility of plant-assisted BiVO₄ synthesis, but the available evidence does not justify a general conclusion that it is inherently greener or more effective than conventional synthesis. Future work should prioritise direct route-to-route comparisons, reproducible extract characterisation, realistic water matrices, and quantitative environmental inventories.

Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!